U flag and black flag
The situation
After two general recalls the committee flies a black flag (or a U flag) for the next start. In the final minute Leo is just over the line, inside the triangle between the line and the first mark.
The question
What happens to Leo, and is it different for the U flag versus the black flag?
The ruling
Leo is disqualified without a hearing for being in the triangle during the last minute. With the U flag (rule 30.3) he's DSQ — but if the whole start is recalled or abandoned, he may start again. With the black flag (rule 30.4) he's DSQ and cannot be redeemed even if there's a general recall and restart; his number is posted and he's done for that race. Both are far harsher than the I flag, so under these flags you start conservatively.
U flag: over-early in the last minute = DSQ (but a restart wipes it). Black flag: DSQ that a restart does NOT wipe.
Opens the situation on the boat-length grid — scrub it and see exactly how the boats meet. Free, no account needed.
Rules cited
See the underlying rule: Rule 30 — U / Z / Black Flag — the Triangle.
Related cases
- Round-the-ends (I flag) · Starting
With the fleet pushing the line, the committee starts the sequence with code flag I. In the last minute before the gun, Sam is over the line early, near the middle.
- The Z flag · Starting
After two general recalls the committee flies the Z flag for the next start. In the last minute Pip is just over the line, inside the triangle between the line and the first mark.
- Over early — going back · Starting
The start gun fires and the race committee hails sail numbers and flies code flag X (individual recall). Maya sees she was over the line early (OCS) and turns back to restart, sailing back toward the pre-start side while the rest of the fleet beats away on starboard.
- Shutting the door at the pin · Starting
Lining up for a pin-end start, Ari is the leeward boat — right next to the pin — with boats stacked up to windward of her. To keep them off the favoured pin, she luffs up and holds them out.