Coaching during the race
The situation
Struggling in fresh breeze, a sailor's coach motors alongside and shouts tactical advice — which way to go and when to tack.
The question
Is taking coaching or other outside help during a race allowed?
The ruling
No. Rule 41 forbids a boat from receiving help from an outside source while racing, with limited exceptions: help for someone ill, injured or in danger; help to get clear after a capsize or grounding; information freely available to all boats; and unsolicited information from a disinterested source. A coach shouting which way to go is outside help and breaks rule 41. Cheering is fine — live tactical coaching during the race is not.
No coaching or outside help while racing (rule 41) — except for safety, or to get clear after a capsize.
Opens the situation on the boat-length grid — scrub it and see exactly how the boats meet. Free, no account needed.
Rules cited
- Rule 41 — Outside Help
Related cases
- A capsized boat ahead · Any Time
Charging downwind, Ava sees a boat just ahead that has capsized, the sailor in the water beside it, right in her path.
- You fouled someone — now what? · Any Time
Beating upwind, Jonah on port tack doesn't quite clear a starboard-tack boat, who has to luff sharply to avoid him. There's no contact and no damage, but Jonah knows he broke the rule.
- Contact and damage · Any Time
Two Optis collide at a mark and one cracks her hull. The right-of-way boat says it wasn't her fault, so she keeps racing.
- Winning isn't everything · Any Time
Already well clear in the lead, a sailor deliberately turns back to sit on a rival from another club and slow her down out of spite — with no benefit to his own race.